Homeschooling – Controlling or Pro-active?

Actually, you’d think I was going to say definitely the latter, but I’m not. I don’t have a problem with admitting to being controlling. So I’m not going to try and justify myself, oh no – I am, in fact, going to claim “controlling” back from the dark side! I think controlling and pro-active are the same thing. Goodness, when Nelson Mandela quotes the William Henley poem in the film Invictus, “I am the master of my fate: I am the captain of my soul”, I’m sure I’m not the only one who gave him a standing ovation from the sofa! It has been said that the way you picture life says a great deal about the way you will approach it, whether you see it as an adventure, a journey, an endurance test… I would think however, that whatever picture you have of life, we all have in common an experience of “the bludgeonings of chance”. Now hear me out, before you think, what the heck has all this got to do with homeschooling. People are complicated, me included, but I have a point to make.

We were chatting this week in the staff room, over our lunchboxes, about various things and I happened to mention one of my strange habits – that of reading the last page of a book first. I have only ever met one other person who does this so I’m willing to admit that I’m quirky. Anyway, someone said “do you like to be in control?” and I said “yes!” but thought, less politely, “Doh!! Of course! Who doesn’t?”. I mean really, whoever consciously says to themselves “well, I’m just happy to let things happen to me and other people can run my life”? Nowt wrong with enjoying some surprises along the way, I don’t mean that, but I can’t think that anyone with a healthy sense of self would purposely relinquish control of their lives. My daughter is five and she already says “mummy, I can’t wait to be grown up so you won’t boss me around!” She totally wants to be in the driving seat – quite literally actually, she was about three when she first expressed a desire to drive herself to nursery! And showed great self-belief that she was capable of it too! Come to think of it, Mae was about 20 weeks old when she made it quite clear to me that she had no intention of eating that disgusting baby rice I was trying to shovel into her.

About my strange reading habits – my logic is simple. However strange you think it is, nobody but nobody enjoys that feeling you have when you read a book and it’s got a rubbish ending. Or watch a film (yes, I do look up film synopses online). I really hate it and it seemed a simple solution to avoiding that feeling you have of wasting all that time in your life hoping for a different ending. Free from the worry of that I can relax and enjoy the twists and turns on the page, or on screen, that lead to the satisfactory conclusion. And I never have to say, apart from in real life of course, “well, that was disappointing”. Obviously I’m only talking about reading, not real life, but I think it’s a great little example of ‘good controlling’. Making pro-active decisions.

Homeschooling is a much better example. And now I warm to my theme. You bring this little life into the world – and I always have a moment during my pregnancies when I think “Oh my God. Am I doing the right thing?” Usually when something happens that reminds me how vulnerable we are to “the bludgeonings of chance”. Just watching the news can bring one of those moments on when you’re pregnant. You think “what kind of world am I bringing my precious child in to?” and “How am I going to explain that?”. My children are mixed race and I’m dreading the day when I have to explain that, despite their extraordinary beauty and intelligence, some ignorant people will judge them inferior because of the colour of their skin. Becoming a parent can seem terrifying. Terrifyingly wonderful.

Our instinct is to protect and control everything which the new little life, for which we are so enormously responsible, comes into contact with. To what degree that nurturing takes place, as well as the length of time it continues, varies according to geography and across history. The ultimate goal is the same – an adult who is strong enough to take their independent place in the world. We parents are, mostly, all aiming for the same thing.

What I don’t understand is, why someone who does not know my child, someone who I myself know nothing about, could be more capable of nurturing my child into independence than I am. It is a truth universally acknowledged…that a single man in possession of a good fortune must be in want of a wife… oops, sorry, got caught in a Jane Austen loop there… what I meant to say was, it is a truth universally acknowdged that “the law is an ass”, to quote Mr Bumble in Dickens. I’m rather partial myself to e.e.cummings: “a politician is an arse upon/which everyone has sat except a man”. Or, in plain prose, most people agree that the powers that run a country are very flawed. But, here is the odd thing, most people are quite happy to then have those powers decide what happens to their child for the majority of it’s life from the age of 5 upwards. Isn’t that strange. At least as strange as always reading the last page in a book first I’d say! I’m not simply being anti-politics here, I’m being anti not questioning that power, examining it’s motives and assessing to what degree you are happy for it to affect your life, or the lives of those you love. Talk about leaving it to fate. The point is not the choice you make, that is every parent’s right, the point is whether you even made a choice.

So then, to end on a flourish: I am happy to declare that I am proud of being controlling! I have no intention of relinquishing my parental responsibilities in any way or to any body. For sixteen short, short years I am not only the Captain of my own soul but I have a little boat tied alongside and I will not set it adrift into the big, wide sea until I am absolutely certain that it is prepared and fully equipped. I know I will need, at various times, to call on the skill of others, but I will be sure before I call that those other people really are the best people for the job and that they know who is ultimately in charge. That is called leadership. Captaincy. Being pro-active – which, by the way, can be defined as: creating or controlling a situation by causing something to happen rather than responding to it after it has happened.


About helenshomeschool

A mummy and a teacher. Enjoying teaching my own three children. Hoping to inspire other parents to do likewise. View all posts by helenshomeschool

4 responses to “Homeschooling – Controlling or Pro-active?

  • Simon Knight

    How can you judge, just from the last page, whether or not the ending of a book is satisfactory?

    For example, the last paragraph [arguably the last page depending on edition read] of George Orwell’s 1984 below:

    “He gazed up at the enormous face. Forty years it had taken him to learn what kind of smile was hidden beneath the dark moustache. O cruel, needless misunderstanding! O stubborn, self-willed exile from the loving breast! Two gin-scented tears trickled down the sides of his nose. But it was all right, everything was all right, the struggle was finished. He had won the victory over himself. He loved Big Brother.”

    How can you tell from this whether it is a “good” ending or not, without an understanding of the journey Winston Smith has taken to arrive at this conclusion?

    I realise I may be missing the point of your post somewhat, but I find it deeply offensive on behalf of all authors everywhere that you would base your opinion on whether or not a book is worthy of your reading it based on a highly subjective critical appraisal of the last few paragraphs of text which by your own admission have been taken completely out of the context in which they were designed to be read. 😉

    My Gran used to read the last page first as well, and was subjected to much the same scorn and derision from yours truly.

    • helenshomeschool

      hmmm, well, I would have read “two gin-scented tears” and that would have tipped me off that all was not well in the last paragraph! My definition of good does not usually involve gin-scented tears. I have been caught out once or twice but 99% of the time it gives you enough of a “flavour”. I have read ‘1984’ actually, compulsory for A-level History. Given the choice I wouldn’t have even bothered to read the last page, just the blurb would have made me put it straight back on the shelf. But I do sometimes read books I’m not drawn to if a good friend recommends them, like Terry Pratchett, who I really like now.

  • jaw123456

    Touche! I so agree, that we Mama’s are the most able to nurture and raise up our children. Thank you for your post!

  • Simon Knight

    Please ignore my post above – sounded better in my head. Not offended at all – honest! 😀

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: